Money Trauma: How Growing Up Without Effects Our Relationship With Money Now

Money Trauma: How Growing Up Without Effects Our Relationship With Money Now

Poverty … is money trauma. Unlike that which we usually identify with trauma – poor parenting, a car accident, a violent attack – faceless institutions are almost always in the mix. Whether it’s the rogues of Wall Street and the banking system, the callous bureaucrats of various governments, or administrators at the VA, a faceless and careless entity is at the other end of the impoverished one’s need. Not want. Need.

That trauma shows up in my office, among those who rationally know they have plenty, but are constantly driven by a sense of never having enough. By those who are miserable in their jobs but terrified at even manageable risk factors in pursuing, instead, work more satisfying to them and more helpful to the world. By those compulsively resist opening their ledgers, looking up their account balance, or in any way checking their goals against the realities of their current finances. When you’re raising a family, or closing in on retirement, that becomes a huge problem.

Two years after my father was born, irresponsibility in the investment world led to a nearly world-wide financial crash. For my father’s family, the Great Depression had terrible repercussions, and even though, as a psychiatrist, my father did well, he never overcame the trauma that tore him from his family. His fears, his paradoxical behavior with his children, generous one minute, starving us the next (quite literally), led me to avoid the issue of money altogether. That gap in education was fortunately provided by a dear friend, my first partner, but I have never forgotten the dread that the mere mention of money once woke in me…as I know it continued to for him.

Funny, how we acknowledge the impact of violence and injury, the impact of sexual abuse, even the impact of neglect…but I have never had someone start therapy in order to address the trauma resulting from poverty. I’m not sure why that is, and maybe I’m missing it, but perhaps, while I think we all get the devastation of lack, personally and globally, identifying it as trauma, and psychologically impactful, is not something I’ve seen discussed. Yet when my clients start exploring this area, it is as loaded, if not more, than the abuse many of them came in initially seeking help for. Entwined within it, we find family shame, and  the effect of frightened, stressed, and therefore often ill-tempered parents.

Trauma freezes. In trauma, by definition, we are stuck. Stuck in the past, stuck in our behaviors, stuck in our reactions. When, even though we know we are no longer that impoverished kid stealing the other kids’ lunches at recess, that we now have a decent salary and even a little in savings, that we feel the imminent threat of destitution. What is that but a particularly heinous form of hypervigilence, and that our nervous systems are almost always in survival mode?

As a writer, I know that one of the cardinal rules of blogging as a therapist is that I end on a hopeful note, even upbeat. I can’t think of any, can you? And if you can’t, and you’re willing, let me know how the trauma of financial poverty impacted you.

PHOTO BY DOROTHEA LANGE

To view the main article, click here

Responses:

I have found a helpful antidote to that frozen fear of not enough is to make a donation – small enough to be genuinely affordable – to an organization such as seva or kiva. For years I allowed my ego to run the donation boat, insisting that if I didnt give magnanimously (ie, something I really couldnt afford), it was shameful to give at all. Then I read a wonderful story about a shoeshine man who gave $5 a week for years and years, his total donations in the thousands. So now I celebrate those $10 and $15 donations and am truely humbled when I receive notice of a return on a kiva loan of $3.25. and am enriched in many many ways. — Nancy W., 6/24/14

Nancy, it is weird how much we belittle those seemingly small and yet cumulative acts of generosity, financial and otherwise. Especially local programs and nonprofits really count on those small donations from many sources, and they do add up! But even more, it feels friendly…I think if I gave a friend who was in need a gift of $10-15, I’d probably feel pretty good; why that goes out the window when I’m making a contribution, I don’t understand. Will ponder on that one…Thanks.

 

 

Please note that all comments are moderated. The blog author will review your comment and reply. Thank you for helping to keep our community SPAM free. I would also like to publish your helpful responses, unless you advise me not to.

4 Comments

  1. I am 54 and contemplating and studying how to live off the grid or how to successfully live as a homeless person. My whole life has been a financial mess. I have no money, work at a job where I sit at a desk and data input, which I hate. Have bad credit and feel trapped with no way out. The situation has always seemed impossible. Money = dread to me. And I’m always living in a state of lack consciousness. I even meditate, do yoga, pray and use affirmations and am fairly intelligent and it seems as though there is a constant ‘lack’ cloud hanging over my head that I just can’t seem to shake. It’s as though some power has a hold on me. I am miserable. I was traumatized as a child by my mother being subservient and dependent on a man for financial support; my step-father, an alcoholic abuser. She was always stressed about money & step-dad always complaining about money. Getting help is difficult as ‘free’ therapist’s don’t generally have experience with this subject and I’m told I just need to work. And I do work, but haven’t been able to freely work at what I love to do. So I’m feeling like just giving up an becoming homeless. I recently was told to try EMDR, which is not within my budget. Any words or help would be greatly appreciated.

    • Marylynn, please don’t give up. You’re not alone in living the equation, “money = dread.” I don’t know if you’re in Denver, but there are low cost options here, including PeopleHouse’s Affordable Counseling Program. The truth I’ve found is that, with what you have, which is developmental trauma, there’s a strongly embodied feeling of stuckness, aka thwarted response, that no amount of “just move on” can ever really help. Is it hard for you to be around others? Often, this kind of trauma leaves us feeling deeply isolated…sometimes a helpful interim step is to find a free yoga class, or other gentle movement, that can help you physically move out of that “stuck” place. It’s hard to take that first step, but I know that if you reach, and continue to bravely reach, someone on the other end is going to reach back. And keep me in the loop, please…

  2. I have found a helpful antidote to that frozen fear of not enough is to make a donation – small enough to be genuinely affordable – to an organization such as seva or kiva. For years I allowed my ego to run the donation boat, insisting that if I didnt give magnanimously (ie, something I really couldnt afford), it was shameful to give at all. Then I read a wonderful story about a shoeshine man who gave $5 a week for years and years, his total donations in the thousands. So now I celebrate those $10 and $15 donations and am truely humbled when I receive notice of a return on a kiva loan of $3.25. and am enriched in many many ways.

    • Nancy, it is weird how much we belittle those seemingly small and yet cumulative acts of generosity, financial and otherwise. Especially local programs and nonprofits really count on those small donations from many sources, and they do add up! But even more, it feels friendly…I think if I gave a friend who was in need a gift of $10-15, I’d probably feel pretty good; why that goes out the window when I’m making a contribution, I don’t understand. Will ponder on that one…Thanks.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *